"Columbus and the Indians," by Theodore Rosebury, was printed first in the April, 1974 issue of MONTHLY REVIEW and reprinted in the July-August, 1992.
Concerning whether syphilis was an American export to Europe, he writes: "I am even more convinced that the old story is a myth and ought to be discarded (p.61-62)." After his thoughtful examination of historical evidence in light of his medical knowledge, he concludes: "If I were voting on a jury I would hold out for acquittal of the American Indian (p. 69)."
R. Chrisjohn