Review of Sokal & Bricmonts' _FASHIONABLE NONSENSE_ in NYTimes Book Review

JKSCHW at aol.com JKSCHW at aol.com
Sun Nov 15 14:15:14 PST 1998


In a message dated 98-11-15 15:31:46 EST, you write:

<< Sokal and Bricmont have, in my estimation, shown themselves to be little

more than mean spirited bullies. >>

And the theorists they abuse have shown themselves to be pretentious scientiufic ignoramuses. Besides "bully" is an odd word to use about someine who writes a book criticising someone else's view for being wrong and ill- informed. It suggests taht that's not polite, that it's nasty to beat up on the helpless and those unable toi defend themselves--because that is whom bullies pick on. If you want to concede that in the fiueld of science the French theorits are 90-pound weaklings, however, I'll concur.

--jks



More information about the lbo-talk mailing list