Fwd: American Bioethics Advisory Commission Demands...

alec ramsdell a_ramsdell at hotmail.com
Sat Nov 21 14:13:25 PST 1998


Max Sawicky wrote:


>I've always been "pro-choice," but the air has
>been slowly going out of that balloon for a while
>now. I've yet to hear a logically coherent argument
>for it. Any defense of womanhood must, it seems,
>grant some standing to the baby in the womb. And
>it seems incontrovertible that at some point in
>the third trimester, at the least, there IS a
>baby in the womb.

Yet the fetus in the womb is a part of the woman's body, thus she should have control over it. *It is her body*, she's not simply a vessel. Isn't this logically coherent? The timing question is another matter, and I'm not comfortable arguing that either way. I do remember reading an essay by Hannah Arendt on abortion. I remember it very vaguely. Anyone know the essay I'm talking about?

-Alec

______________________________________________________ Get Your Private, Free Email at http://www.hotmail.com



More information about the lbo-talk mailing list