Commentary Goes After Said

Jim heartfield jim at heartfield.demon.co.uk
Thu Aug 26 07:31:47 PDT 1999


In message <l0302090ab3e71030a775@[216.26.6.68]>, CounterPunch <sitka at teleport.com> writes
> [here they are...going after Said the way they did Rigoberta M.--jsc]

I think the difference is that Edward Said did not falsify his life story, whilst, Rigoberta Menchu admits that she did (or more properly that Elizabeth Burgos Debray did).

'It ['I Rogoberta Menchu] is not my life story'.

Notably, Said's defenders are not descending to the absurd 'good lie' position, because they don't have to. -- Jim heartfield



More information about the lbo-talk mailing list