Jim Farmelant
On Mon, 08 Feb 1999 00:03:48 -0800 Sam Pawlett <epawlett at uniserve.com>
writes:
>All this discussion about liberal rights and justice has got me
>thinking
>about the relation between Marxism and justice.Allen Wood developed
>the
>interesting argument that Marx's critique of political economy had
>nothing to do with justice and that capitalism does exploit the
>working
>class but this exploitation is just. Wood explains;
>" He(Marx) equally scorned those who concerned themselves with
>formulating principles of distributive justice and condemning
>capitalism
>in their name. Marx conceives that justice of economic transactions as
>their correspondance to or functionality for the prevailing mode of
>production. Given this conception of justice, Marx very consistently
>concluded that the inhuman exploitation practiced by capitalism
>against
>the workers is not unjust, and does not violate the worker's rights;
>this conclusion constitutes no defense of capitalism, only an attack
>on
>the use of moral conceptions within the proletarian movement. Marx saw
>the task of the proletarian movement in his time as one of
>self-definition, discipline and self-criticism based on scientific
>self-understanding. He left for later stages of the movement the task
>of
>planning the future society which it is the historic mission of the
>movement to bring forth."
> To summarize, law and justice are judicial concepts. Judicial
>concepts
>belong to the superstructure which is determined by the mode of
>production. A society will thus have a conception of justice that fits
>and grows naturally out of its mode of production. Capitalist
>exploitation is just in a capitalist mode of production but unjust in
>a
>communist mode of production. It is wrong therefore, to ascribe some
>universal form of justice applicable to all modes of production. A
>future communist society will not be 'more just' than capitalism, it
>will simply have a conception of justice that fits its mode of
>production; a mode of production where capitalist exploitation doesn't
>exist.
>
>Wood fleshes out this argument in his book _Karl Marx_ and his article
>"Marx and the Critique of Justice" Philosophy and Public Affairs, V1
>no.
>3 1972.
>
>Any thoughts on this argument?
>
>Sam Pawlett
>
>
___________________________________________________________________ You don't need to buy Internet access to use free Internet e-mail. Get completely free e-mail from Juno at http://www.juno.com/getjuno.html or call Juno at (800) 654-JUNO [654-5866]