Malcolm X and building a Black Tammany Hall

Doug Henwood dhenwood at panix.com
Tue Jan 5 09:00:38 PST 1999


Charles Brown wrote:


>The failure to see any content
>to a concept of Black
>community seems an
>intellectual reflection of
>the politics of dividing
>the Black community. By
>this standard of unity, no
>community has ever existed.
>For that matter no person
>has ever existed given
>the contradictions within
>individuals. THE Black
>community's unity ebbs and
>flows, but the extreme that
>there is never any unity sufficient
>to designate it as a community
>is a form of nihilism.

Oh come on now - this sounds like some bourgeois objecting to the divisiveness of class analysis. Is there a white community? An American community? A community of Detroit? A world commuinity? In some banal sense these things probably exist, but what Marxist could ever endorse the use of such empty and mystifying phrases? They obscure more than they reveal, either unconsciously or consciously (in the hands of propagandists).

Doug



More information about the lbo-talk mailing list