cross national homicide rate query

Doug Henwood dhenwood at panix.com
Wed Jan 13 08:38:40 PST 1999


seanno at ksu.edu wrote:


>A local newspaper columnist is claiming that the U.S. is the homicide
>"capital of the world" thus the U.S. needs to use the death sentence more
>often. Beside the leap in logic I'm pretty sure the empirical claim is
>false but I'm having trouble hunting down the data. Can anyone help me
>locate cross national data on homicide rates?

The UN Development Program(me)'s Human Development Report 1998 has a table, no. 36, called "Social stress and social change," which covers only the "industrial" countries. It reports "intentional homicides by men per 100,000 people, 1985-90." The average for all "high human development" countries is 4.8; the US is 12.4, the highest by far. Next is Finland, at 4.1. Canada, 2.7. UK, 1.6. Japan, 0.9. Among the next tier, the "medium human development," Russia leads the pack at 9.0.

The U.S. murder rate has fallen pretty sharply since those numbers were collected, but I doubt it's hit Finnish levels. Russia may now be #1.

There's not much good data from other sources, as far as I know, though I do remember hearing a claim that Brazil has a higher homicide rate than the U.S.

Doug



More information about the lbo-talk mailing list