I can't speak to her allure, personally. But I happily insist that both of Roiphe's books, The Morning After and Last Night in Paradise are amongst the best written on sexual politics in the last decade.
The hostility to Roiphe's work is a measure of the fact that she exposed the shibboleth's of a one-time oppositional movement that is fast becoming the establishment.
The central point is that the feminist movement has become conservative in its sex negativity, effectively coalescing with the moral panics of the Christian right. Who could disagree?
-- Jim heartfield