wicked projects

Margaret mairead at mindspring.com
Sun May 23 12:12:00 PDT 1999


Kelley responded to Doug:


>>If our constitution protects our precious liberties, why do we
>>criminalize more behavior and jail more people than just about any other
>>country on earth?
>
>because we have the most highly developed form of capitalism on the planet?
> relatedly, because we have the most individualistic ethos on the planet?
>because prisons are cheaper than schools for warehousing the surplus army
>of reserve labor?
>and, how about because the US is a capitalist juggernaut at full bore in
>the nearly complete absence of civil society and a vital public sphere?

Wooo! SAY it, Sister!


>the relentless critique crowd
>never seems to have anything else to offer, accept some vague claim that
>it'll be all better once we get rid of capitalism.

Yes! Yes! And doesn't it get right up your nostril?


>these arguments against the constitution are based on an incredibly crude
>and under-theorized notion of the state as some sort of monolithic,
>univocal entity. it's rather undialectiacal and typical of what marx
>called 'crude socialism' to think that we shouldn't concern ourselves with
>the practical politics of such things because they're ick! the stuff of
>bourgeois liberalism. [see marx's letter to arnold ruge 1843]

When I joined this list, I was hoping to find a group of 'sewer socialists', concerned, like the immigrant ashkenazi socialists represented by Alinsky, with the bricks-and-mortar problems of building _real_ socialism, building a better life for everyone. But all there seems to be, here, are what Kelley calls 'the relentless critique crowd'. What a waste!

Perfection-or-nothing positions may warm the cockles (and mussels) of our self-satisfaction, but they do little good in the real world. And if we're not trying to do good in the real world, what the hell kind of socialists are we, anyway?



More information about the lbo-talk mailing list