reverence for the constitution

Mark Rickling rickling at netzero.net
Tue May 25 16:12:19 PDT 1999


I don't quite buy your "corporate liberalism" interpretation of 7(a) and the Wagner Act. IMO, the Wagner act is pretty damn radical, as far twentieth century American law goes. Contrary to what Thomas Ferguson and Colin Gordon, to name a political scientist and a historian who have in recent times advanced the corporate liberalism thesis regarding New Deal labor legislation, have written, business leaders as a class opposed the Wagner Act, and (I am almost certain) section 7(a) of the NIRA.

mark

Michael Hoover wrote:
>to what extent is there a right to strike in US?...aren't most
>public employees prohibited from doing so?...did Section 7(a) of
>the National Industrial Recovery Act, which guaranteed the right
>employees to organize and to bargain collectively also establish
>a right to strike?...after all, 7(a) was not result of labor union
>agitation or union leadership advocacy, but culmination of efforts
>by corporate leaders who favored economic regulation and stability
>(their model was WW1 War Industries Board)...NIRA, in effect, also
>legalized cartels in US industry...
>
>did Wagner Act (a boon, no doubt, to US labor movement), which
>made 7(a) permanent when Recovery Act expired, guarantee a
>right to strike?...National Labor Relations Board may have been
>authorized to issue cease and desist orders to employers committing
>unfair labor practices as defined by law and to certify bargaining
>reps for unions, but wasn't principal purpose of legislation to
>safeguard interstate commerce from interruption by kind of strike
>wave that erupted (unexpectedly) following passage of 7(a)?...in
>other words, institutionalize and regulate capital-labor relations...
>
>isn't Wagner is the 'liberal' side of labor-management relations to
>Taft-Hartley's 'conservative' side outlawing jurisdictional strikes
>& secondary strikes, and providing for use of injunction and other
>'cooling-off' procedures where strike or threat thereof threatens
>the 'national welfare'... Michael Hoover
>
>
>
________________________________________________________ NetZero - We believe in a FREE Internet. Shouldn't you? Get your FREE Internet Access and Email at http://www.netzero.net/download/index.html



More information about the lbo-talk mailing list