Is Buchanan an antisemite?
grinker at mweb.co.za
Sun Nov 21 11:21:25 PST 1999
>I'd be interested to hear whether an anti-semite in the current context
>(Pat Buchanan) is (a) someone whe finds semitic peoples repellent or (b)
>someone who is willing to create/perpetuate the perception that semitic
>peoples are repellant for the purpose of advancing an other
>cause/personal gain. Or is anti-semitism inclusive of both of those
>groups? Somehow it seems that there ought to be a distinction.
How about Arno Mayer's distinctions (from his excellent book "Why did the
heavens not darken? - The Final Solution in History"):
Judeophobia = personal prejudice
Anti-Semitism = the institutionalised forms taken by such prejudice, forms
which are often but not always political/advocacy of such institutionalised
Anti-Judaism = hostile feelings or actions directed against the Jewish
religion or Jews as adherents of that religion (i.e. religious as opposed to
I'm not sure where Buchanan fits in.
More information about the lbo-talk