Mugger writes...

Doug Henwood dhenwood at panix.com
Wed Nov 24 13:30:35 PST 1999


Gosh, this list is becoming unpaid fodder for New York Press columnists, thanks to some busy faxer. Who is it, someone from Dissent?

This is from Russ "Mugger" Smith's column in this week's issue:


>Oh Dear, I've Offended Someone
>
>Last week I received an anonymous fax that contained Katha Pollitt's
>early admission entry for the National Magazine Awards. It's quite a
>stunning piece, actually, a reaction to a friend's critique of
>NYPress, and I can only hope The Nation's white feminist receives
>her due.
>
>It reads: "'A yeasty brew'? Sure-if you like to wash down your lunch
>with a big glass of fermented cat pee!
>
>"Those ubiquitous NYPress boxes are pretty full at the end of the
>week. At Film Forum (hip downtown theater much-frequented by the
>young and restless) the huge stack of Tuesday's NYPresses had barely
>been touched by Saturday afternoon. Russ Smith is pretty good at
>getting publicity for himself in the mainstream media he claims to
>despise (in which he certainly seems to take himself very
>seriously), but you never hear a column or story in NYPress
>discussed outside its pages, and almost none of its writers either.
>(I think so far the most famous writer they've developed is Amy
>Sohn, who wrote a column about her sexual humiliations, and went on
>to write for the trashy New York Post for about a minute.) "Can you
>name their movie critic and describe his/her taste? You don't even
>see tag lines from their reviews in ads for books, records or
>movies. "I should mention in interests of truth in advertising that
>Russ Smith offered me a column. I declined-politely too-and that is
>probably why they go after me so often. Some people just can't take
>rejection! Still, it shows you what a jerk Russ Smith is-obviously,
>he thought I was a pretty interesting writer when he wanted me to
>work for him! But once I said no thanks I became a boring liberal, a
>whiny feminist, a mediocre member of the journalistic establishment
>with nothing whatsoever to say.
>
>"Hard to respect a guy like that."

That, of course, is Katha's post to this list of November 15. Smith comments:


>Indeed. It's true that I offered "whiny feminist" Pollitt a column a
>few years ago and also accurate that she politely declined. But
>Katha, hon, it wasn't for your dazzling prose that I wanted to add
>you to our eclectic roster of writers. Rather, at NYPress, unlike
>The Nation, we encourage wide diversity of opinions. Who knows, one
>day faux-populist Michael Moore, if he took a few writing courses,
>might wind up in our pages.

Russ, if you're reading this, is there a reprint fee on its way?

Doug



More information about the lbo-talk mailing list