Merchant marine? I'm genuinely impressed. I was in the Army for three years, but from what I know of the MMs, yours probably was the tougher gig.
What I meant by "vibrant" work is physical labor that leads to something desirable -- in my case, a new fenceline and car port. As for honesty, well, as you say, opinions may differ.
I'm intrigued by the hostility to some of my posts in this thread. I don't think I've said anything outrageous; and to the degree I've been misunderstood, I've tried to clarify my position. There's a certain level of defensiveness here, what with the "anti-intellectual" and "macho" comebacks. Jesus, you'd think I pissed off Norman Podhoretz!
DP