Theoretical Twiddling and Romantic Fiction and Epic

Doug Henwood dhenwood at panix.com
Mon Feb 14 09:29:32 PST 2000


Carrol Cox wrote:


>I absolutely deny that what is
>called psychology can explain that fact -- it can only give
>labels which, as Marx said of "Providence," are only a sort
>of paraphrase of the facts, not an explanation.

Why is it ok when Marx, after observing all the disparate features of actually existing capitalism - product markets, labor markets, money markets, firms, workers, nations - posits a law of value, and makes generalized observations about prices, competition, etc., but when psychologists observe all the disparate features of human behavior and make generalizations, they're just paraphrasing facts?

Doug



More information about the lbo-talk mailing list