nationalism & imperialism (jim o'connor)

Barbara Laurence cns at cats.ucsc.edu
Mon Jan 17 17:46:05 PST 2000


Max, I asked the question in the first place because I've met quite a few radicals who have trouble with the concept that the US is an imperialist country, which means that its national ideologies of individualism, self-help, individual autonomy (all a crock, see Chapter 1 of my Accumulation Crisis book) are used to legitimate its expansionism. At one time territorial, now of course money and capital, cultural, political, military. The US justifies its imperialist policies by bedrock beliefs that Americans hold (or are supposed to hold) about themselves as "Americans." The US projects its ideologies on to the world, then projects its power to enforce what it regards as natural law. There's no compromise with this set-up. You're in or you're out. Like the mob. Normally sensible people get starry-eyes about "America" beating up some poor unfortunate abroad in the name of life, liberty and the pursuit of Noreaga.

I have no idea how to break this down, or what might or will break it down. Problem is of course that the american ideology is the only thing keeping the country together.

I don't think unions are "nationalistic" unless and until they mobilize such patriotic sentiments in the name of the American worker. Lots of what some call nationalism is just good trade unionism.

Note how seemingly impossible it is to break the hold of US nationalist imperialist ideology. Mere facts won't do it. Even the US can't project power around the globe any time it wishes, but military and foreign policy failures never seem to make much difference for the ways Americans think about themselves. For me, the most dangerous fact about America is that its people never went throught a period of shame for slavery, Native American geonocide, Vietnam, and half a dozen other things. Thus the country will support just about any crackpot policy and action, overseas, even the most bizzare and cruel, sadistic, policy in Iraq today.

Yours, Jim O'C



More information about the lbo-talk mailing list