CNN on Graham

Chris Burford cburford at gn.apc.org
Thu Jun 22 23:38:16 PDT 2000


For the maximum ritual benefits (I am sure Wojtek is right to talk of ritual) the execution should be as public and as gruesome as possible. Why does the US constitution barr death through torture?

It is interesting that through the rise in judicial executions in the last quarter of the 20th century, the mode of execution appears to have switched increasingly to death through intravenous injection.

Chris Burford London

At 08:32 22/06/00 -0700, you wrote:
>>All this is a preamble to say from the other side of the Atlantic what I
>>hope is more than a mere prejudice, how utterly barbaric is US practice of
>>the death penalty.
>
>You don't know the half of it, Chris. The NY Times had an article June
>21, "Intimate View of the Death House: Exhibition on Sing Sing Tells of
>Last Meals and Final Moments," on a current exhibition concerning the 614
>people (apparently a record for U.S. prisons) who were executed at Sing
>Sing Correctional Facility in New York State from 1891 to 1963, when the
>state's death penalty was suspended (it was reinstated in 1995 but has not
>yet been used again). Here's one excerpt from the Times' article:
>
>"Death [from Sing Sing's electric chair] was not always instantaneous, Mr.
>[Scott] Christianson [a former prison official who organized the
>exhibition as a protest against the death penalty's reinstitution] pointed
>out.
>Sometimes the condemned person caught fire. There was a debate about
>whether death was caused by the electricity or the autopsy that quickly
>followed.
>
>"One autopsy report from 1951 in the exhibition notes: 'The cerebellum
>seen from the posterior surfaces is opaque and grayish in color. It has a
>boiled appearance. The whole brain is uncomfortably warm to the touch.'
>
>"'It is my contention that one of the reasons legal autopsies were made a
>requirement was not only an attempt to determine the nature of death, but
>also to ensure death,' Mr. Christianson said."
>
>Carl
>________________________________________________________________________
>Get Your Private, Free E-mail from MSN Hotmail at http://www.hotmail.com



More information about the lbo-talk mailing list