working class civil society (wasRe: Class Ceiling--Ehrenreich)

[Ken Hanly]

When you say "moralizing" is wrong I assume you do not mean to moralize. I
assume the
conclusion to your enthymeme is: All moral(ist)  judgments are judgments that
reduce to religion.
So no atheists can make moral judgments?

     "All moralist judgments reduce to Platonism". No wonder Whitehead said
that all philosophy was just a footnote to Plato! By the way is there a proof
or evidence for your proposition anywhere?

   Cheers, Ken Hanly

Carrol Cox wrote:


>
> Others can carry on the argument about Ehrenreich. I'm not concerned
> right now. I say *moralizing* is wrong. It's false. It reflects a failure
> to understand the world correctly. All moralist judgments reduce to
> Platonism and Platonism reduces to religion.
>