>But whether the sanctions are causing this crisis is not a question
>that is settled just by eye-witness observation of the suffering
>that is going on. It requires evaluating the counter-factual above.
Well, instead of a counter-factual, we might see a real (if gradual) end of international sanction (though not of American embargo), if we are to believe Stratfor (which I'm not sure we can always):
***** From: <alert at stratfor.com> To: redalert at stratfor.com Subject: IRAQ - SANCTIONS Date: Sun, 19 Nov 2000 20:13:59 -0600 (CST)
Stratfor.com's WorldView - 20 November 2000
Meanwhile, Back in Iraq By George Friedman
Buried deep in the American subconscious lurks the specter of a 10-year old war. American aircraft still fly daily combat air patrols and conduct air strikes. U.S. Navy ships still ply the water and nearby, ground forces remain at the ready.
The ongoing U.S. and British action against Iraq remains the ultimate in low intensity conflict. It is not so much a forgotten war as one whose goal is unattainable. Neither the destruction of Saddam Hussein nor the restoration of an arms inspection regime is now possible.
Last week, the Russians helped make these military operations meaningless. In a new drive, the Putin government is signaling that it will help the Iraqi government put a formal end to a decade of UN economic sanctions. By doing so, the Russians aim to halt the U.S. and British patrols and gain for themselves billions of dollars by developing Iraq's western oil fields....
...Everyone from the French to the Syrians has quite publicly violated the sanctions in some way. The United States has responded by pretending that the violations weren't violations.
But the American strategy of pretending just became much more difficult. Last Tuesday, Russian Foreign Minister Igor Ivanov visited Baghdad. He carried with him a letter from Russian President Vladimir Putin. The letter called for an end to U.S. and British air strikes against Iraqi targets. The letter also declared, the Russian leadership's firm intention to obtain a rapid political settlement to the Iraqi problem, including the lifting of sanctions against Iraq.
In an interview with Al-Djazira television reported by Interfax, Ivanov stated, "It is necessary to work out steps that would provide for the carrying out of UN Security Council resolutions concerning Iraq and guarantee reliable control over banned military programs." The Russian foreign minister also called for a UN dialogue on the subject but said that the talks are in deadlock and implied that Iraqis are not the ones responsible for the delay.
The Russians are working hard to strengthen ties with Iraq and in the process will strain relations with the United States. A Russian airline, Vnukovo, is going to begin regular service to Baghdad, although it will be labeled as a special charter. A group of Russian scientists recently visited Baghdad to protest sanctions.
However, this has as much to do with oil as it does with global power politics. In a memorandum to UN Secretary General Kofi Anan, Ivanov noted that sanctions against Iraq have cost Russia $30 billion over the past decade. Ivanov got this number from Yuri Shafranik, who leads the committee for Russian cooperation with Iraq and is a director of the Russian Central Fuel Company.
Russian firms are in danger of losing access to Iraq's vast western oil fields and now the Russian government is using foreign policy as a lever in this struggle. Recently, Amer Rasheed, Iraq's oil minister, threatened to cancel a contract with Russia's giant Lukoil to develop the Kurna oil field in western Iraq, one of the largest in the world. The Russians say it has the potential to produce 200 million tons of oil. The Iraqis complained that the Russians have done nothing to develop the field; the Russians countered that the sanctions make that impossible.
The Iraqis agree and appear to have made a quid pro quo quite clear: If the Russians will get rid of the sanctions, the Iraqis will give them the keys to the western oil fields. The Russian government has a lot to lose in Iraq, and little to lose in challenging the Americans at the United Nations. This is a perfect marriage between geopolitical interests and economic ones.
It's important to understand that this is not just talk. The Russians want to develop the oil fields. The Iraqis will pull the contract if they don't do so. Therefore, the Russian government will engineer a fig leaf solution to weapons inspections, helping the UN create a regime that is wholly ineffective. This will allow Moscow to claim that Iraq has met the conditions for ending the sanctions.
Although the British and the Americans will object, they will run into serious problems at the Security Council. Both the Chinese and the French will buy into a pseudo-inspection system. As important, the Israeli-Palestinian confrontation has increased anti- Americanism throughout the Arab world. Recent events will make the American position harder to maintain.
While in Baghdad, the Russian delegation insisted that it had no geopolitical interests in the region. Ironically, the leader of the delegation of Russian scientists was the director of the country's geopolitical institute. Pure coincidence, of course. _______________________________________________
SUBSCRIBE to our new service. Just go to http://www.stratfor.com/subscribe.html _______________________________________________
(c) 2000 Stratfor, Inc. _______________________________________________ SUBSCRIBE to the free, daily Global Intelligence Update. Click on http://www.stratfor.com/home/giu/subscribe.asp UNSUBSCRIBE by clicking on http://www.stratfor.com/home/giu/unsub.asp _______________________________________________ Stratfor.com 504 Lavaca, Suite 1100 Austin, TX 78701 Phone: 512-583-5000 Fax: 512-583-5025 Internet: http://www.stratfor.com/ Email: info at stratfor.com *****
From a recent speech made by Tariq Aziz, Vice Prime Minister of Iraq, we can also glean that the sanctions regime is cracking. A ray of hope?
Yoshie