-----Original Message----- From: owner-lbo-talk at lists.panix.com [mailto:owner-lbo-talk at lists.panix.com]On Behalf Of Michael Pugliese Sent: Tuesday, September 12, 2000 12:36 AM To: lbo-talk at lists.panix.com Subject: national journal Professor Finkelstein,please explain to us how the Holocaust /Chomsky, Shahak
Are these unrepresentative quotes from Finkelstein's book?
From a neo-nazi website. Found from a link from the subsequent forward. Thread on upcoming demo on right of return for Palestinians. http://al-awda.org/
Michael Pugliese
http://www.nationaljournal.org/e2000/judaism/questions.htm
Received: 9/11/00 8:44:53 PM From: Itzhak Epstein <Itzhak.Epstein at worldnet.att.net> To: dsanet at quantum.sdsu.edu CC: Subject: Chomsky/Shahak (was:Re: dsanet: ACTION TO DEFEND,,,,,) MIME Ver: 1.0 Attachments:
The author of this message is Itzhak Epstein <Itzhak.Epstein at worldnet.att.net>
Did anybody say Chomsky?
Most of you may have missed my previous dsanet contribution about Noam Chomsky. So I edited and recycled my last message. In this case special attention should be accorded to his collaboration with a certain Israel Shahak.
What follows is somewhat selective but not too slanted. Please click on the urls and reach your own conclusions. I urge others to conduct similar web searches and to see what they get.
1. http://www.noontidepress.com/catalog/zionism.html Search for "shahak" and then see what else they peddle by browsing through the rest of their catalog. http://www.noontidepress.com/catalog/ 2. <http://www.nationaljournal.org/shahakidx.htm> To see the context go to the home-page: <http://www.nationaljournal.org/engl.htm> 3. <http://www.hoffman-info.com/essay8.html> To see the context go to the home-page: http://www.hoffman-info.com/cgi-bin/store/commerce.cgi 4. <http://www.jewwatch.com/jew-genocide-gentilehate.html> click on the homepage link at the bottom of this one.
At 02:23 PM 9/11/2000 -0400, you wrote:
>
>The author of this message is "Jim Devor" <jimdevor at jps.net>
>
>On 10 Sep 2000, at 13:38, you wrote:
>
> > I guess I'm one of those gullible liberals (along with Noam Chomsky and
> > Norman Finkelstein and others who should know better). Had known this
was
> > the agenda I wouldn't have signed their list.
> >
>
> First of all, what makes you think Chomsky DOESN'T share their
>agenda? These days, his anti-zionism is probably far more vehement
>than Arafat's.
>
> Second, would you be as naive if, for example, a group of Sudeten
>Germans were agitating for a "right of return" to the Sudetenland in the
>Czech Republic? How about Indian Hindus' "right of return" to
>Bangledesh? Both of those "expulsions" took place at about the same
>time as the Palestinians'.
>
> Like just about everyone else on this list, I support the
> creation of a
>Palestinian state, BUT only in the context of a two State solution in
>which the civil rights of minorities in BOTH entitities are respected. An
>"inalienable right of return" to particular locations either where ancient
>ancestors or grandparents may have once lived is deliberately intended
>to sabotage that goal. What is so hard in figuring that out?
>
> >
> > I am NOT in favor of driving the Israeli Jews into the sea, I promise.
> >
> As Stokely Carmichael used to say, that's real White of you.
>
>Fraternally,
>
>
>_____________
>Jim Devor jimdevor at jps.net
Itzhak Epstein New York, NY <mailto:itzhak.epstein at worldnet.att.net>