Hamilton

Brad DeLong jbdelong at uclink.berkeley.edu
Wed Aug 22 09:13:17 PDT 2001



>Doug Henwood wrote:
>>
>> [bounced bec of an attachment - by the way, my pal Dan Lazare,
>> Marxist critic of the U.S. constitutional system, is a Hamilton fan
>> who hates Jefferson]
>> > [clip]
>> Whatever happened to the strain of leftism that sees
>> capitalism as an improvement on what existed before,
>> and as a nessessary precursor to socialism?
>>
>
>There are two propositions here, which have no necessary connection:
>
>1. Capitalism was an improvement over pre-capitalist regimes
>
>2. Capitalism was/is a necessary precursor of socialism.
>
>I don't know any basis, except perhaps a religious belief in the
>Doctrine of Progress, for the first proposition.

Perhaps a belief that short life expectancy and high infant mortality are bad things?



More information about the lbo-talk mailing list