Jazz

Uday Mohan udaym at igc.org
Sun Jan 21 07:53:16 PST 2001


Gordon Fitch wrote:
> If it is America's _the_ classical music, then you're going
> to need a new box for Philip Glass, Steve Reich, Harry Partch,
> Brain Eno, etc. I guess Glass and maybe Eno can go in the
> semi-pop box but the others are going to be a problem. They
> aren't jazz and they aren't pop and many people take them
> very, very seriously.

Eno's a Brit. And Reich's been remixed (the "Reich Remixed" CD) by electronica artists. Partch seems too idiosyncratic to be labeled classical. He's certainly not part of any performance canon.


> What differentiates classical from pop in Indian
> is discipline, ambition, and context.

No formal elements? And success in both Indian classical and pop musics require ambition and discipline (from what I've seen as a not very knowledgeable fan of some of it).

Uday



More information about the lbo-talk mailing list