Null on AIDS

Doug Henwood dhenwood at panix.com
Thu Jan 25 07:06:52 PST 2001


Peter van Heusden wrote:


>'Alternative' medicine in my experience largely fails to break from
>many of bad things about medicine under capitalism - the authoritarian
>position of the practitioner,

Who is often deified, invested with mystical healing capacities.


> the focus on symptoms (even if the
>symptoms are broadened into the 'lifestyle' catagory)

I once saw a list of symptoms of "yeast infection," which was an obsession of the alternacrowd a few years ago. It included things like sleeplessness, restlessness, digestive complaints, difficulty concentrating - in other words, classic somatized symptoms of anxiety and depression. Now either the purveyors of these diagnoses - who are usually purveyors of a cure, too - know this, in which case they're frauds, or they don't, in which case they're frauds of a different kind.

My father visited some quack sidekick of Gary Null's for his arthritis. The quack discovered that he was infected with cytomegalovirus. Something like 2/3 of adults carry CMV. But the quack prescribed a round of intravenous vitamin C at $100 a pop (for what must have been pennies worth of vitamin and saline). Thankfully, my father told the guy to get lost, though I'm sure that's an uncommon reaction.

Doug



More information about the lbo-talk mailing list