Christian love

Max Sawicky sawicky at bellatlantic.net
Fri Jul 6 07:04:06 PDT 2001


Critiques of relgion(s) can be constructive, civil, and fair, or they can be bigoted. Pat Buchanan's lifelong jew-baiting is bigotry. The media equation of Islam and exotic irrationality is too. There are softer expressions as well. It is legitimate to condemn religious expression that condemns some alleged miscreant to death for something they said or wrote. It is bigotry to apply such condemnation indiscriminantly, or to apply it to unrelated religious doctrine.

mbs

Yes -- from the likes of Ralph Reed and Pat Robertson. But it is one thing to discriminate against a person of faith, say in civil matters (denying them a home, a loan, a seat in a restaurant solely because of their beliefs); it is another to attack the basis of the faith in print or in oral argument. The latter to me is not "bigotry" any more than anti-Marxism or anti-Hegelianism is "bigotry." Religious thought is, at bottom, philosophical, and thus is open to any or all critiques, mild or harsh, fair or unfair.

DP



More information about the lbo-talk mailing list