Conservative Promotes Racial Divisions to Undermine Welfare State

Max Sawicky sawicky at bellatlantic.net
Thu Jul 19 11:00:39 PDT 2001


He's right that *in and of itself* ethnic homogeneity is conducive to social welfare activism. That doesn't mean that more immigration would make a difference. For one thing, more immigration might make California more homogenous, not less; for two, where a threshold of social fragmentation is passed, more immigrants would not make a difference, and their involvement in labor would favor a progressive result.

The only reason to want to control immigration is for labor defense reasons. Lind is wrong about the public sector effect; immigrants are net contributors to the public sector, not net recipients. People forget the bias in public expenditures towards the elderly, and most immigrants are young.

mbs

An interesting little article arguing for conservatives to promote multicultural divisions and immigration to undermine the welfare state, since conservatives can count on racism to keep people from identifying with the poor of other races. Nice sometimes to see racist strategy so clearly expressed-- Nathan

====== "My Trial Balloon: Immigrants and socialism." Source: National Review Online Published: 18 July 2001 Author: Jonah Goldberg



More information about the lbo-talk mailing list