Richard Pipes

[Justin Schwartz]

Yes, Carrol, please.

Let me say as a sometime Sovietologist that Pipes is a liar and a fraud, 
utterly incompetent as a Soviet scholar. He's actually not bad on 19th 
century Russia, his speciality, but he is so blinded with hatred and 
loathing when it comes to the USSR that he cannot keep on the straight and 
narrow. I don't say this because he's a righwtinger and I'm not. There are 
many right wing scholars of the USSR who have done first rate work: the 
great Merle Fainsod, Robert Conquest (very able), Edward Crankshaw, even 
Leonard Shapiro. Pipes is just no damn good on this stuff.

jks

>
>[This bounced because it was too long. Anyone interested, email
>Carrol for a copy.]
>
>Date: Fri, 16 Mar 2001 20:05:24 -0600
>From: Carrol Cox <cbcox at ilstu.edu>
>Reply-To: cbcox at ilstu.edu
>Subject: The Scholarship of Richard Pipes  [Fwd: Re: BHA: Reply to Sean's 
>reply
>  to me]
>
>Lenin Known and Unknown
>
>The Errors of Richard Pipes: An Abridged List
>
>Lars
_________________________________________________________________
Get your FREE download of MSN Explorer at http://explorer.msn.com