On Selective Pacifism & other Oddities

Kelley kwalker2 at gte.net
Thu Nov 29 08:47:41 PST 2001


At 11:33 AM 11/29/01 -0500, brettk at unicacorp.com wrote:
>These arguments are advanced as support for a larger point, that the
>war is unjustified. As Justin said, the Afghan war does not meet the
>standards of just war theory, or the standards laid out by the UN, namely
>self-defence.

then worries about innocents dying shouldn't be raised, and they especially shouldn't be raised against your opponent in an argument.

so, right here in this exchange, there is MP's response, the concern about innocent civilians in Afghanistan.

don't get me wrong, it's what sickens me about the whole thing, too, but then i haven't been throwing it in doug's or max's or brad's face as an argument against their positions. and, i have an entirely different approach to this whole thing anyway: terrorism isn't something that we can deal with via the war machine OR the US legal machine.

kelley

From the YeahSureRightFW Dept: "If young women go for older men and vice-versa, who cares? The problem is the asymmetries in wealth and power between individuals which make one person more dependent on/vulnerable to the other, usually the woman. If we could eliminate class, innumerable social problems would be solved virtually overnight."

--Brett Knowlton



More information about the lbo-talk mailing list