I still fail to see the fundamental difference. In both cases, you have to develop promising lines of research, continuously evaluate them based on some kind of peer-review process, etc. Putting it in the hands of private industry just splits the process up into competing camps that don't share information.
In the case of consumer goods, where adapting to customer feedback is a large part of the process, private applied research is probably a lot more flexible. But consumer feedback is not an issue in drug development - it's simply a matter of finding "the best drug".
Jim Baird
__________________________________________________ Do You Yahoo!? Get email alerts & NEW webcam video instant messaging with Yahoo! Messenger http://im.yahoo.com