Men & women & obesity

Christopher Rhoades Dÿkema crdbronx at erols.com
Sat Sep 8 10:41:55 PDT 2001


Nobody so fare in this discussion has touched on a great source: Sidney Mintz' SWEETNESS AND POWER: THE PLACE OF SUGAR IN MODERN HISTORY. Sugar was the first industrially produced processed food, and a key element in economic history, central to colonization in many places, the slave trade, and much else. The last chapters show how sugar became a staple in the English working-class diet, replacing earlier, healthier foods. For example --

"Tobacco, sugar, and tea were the first objects within capitalism that conveyed with their use the complex idea that one could become different by consuming differently. This idea has little to do with nutrition or primates or sweet tooth, and less than it appears to have with symbols. But it is closely connected to England's fundamental transformation from a hierarchical, status-based, medieval society to a social-democratic, capitalist and industrial society."

He shows how English working-class people came to fill themselves up on bread and sugary jam with sugared tea giving the illusion that they were eating hot meals. This applied particularly to women and children while men got more protein so that they would have the strength to do physical work. He suggests that this functioned, to an extent, as a means of population control through maintaining a high child mortality rate based on chronic malnutrition of growing kids.

Probably Leslie can confirm the large amount of hidden sugar in the junk food contemporary Americans eat, including items not formally seen as sweet, where it also has some preservative effect.

Another nugget from Mintz --

"Increasing sugar consumption is only one of the ways 'development' changes food habits and choices, of course. While caloric intake probably increases as sugar consumption rises, this increase is partly achieved by substitutions, one of the clearest being the replacement of complex carbohydrates (starches) with simple carbohydrates (sucrose)."

This is one of the more interesting books I've read in the last few years.

Christopher Rhoades Dÿkema



More information about the lbo-talk mailing list