(no subject)

Brad DeLong jbdelong at uclink.berkeley.edu
Thu Sep 13 06:49:45 PDT 2001



> > If 250 deaths in the Al Aqsa intifada create (say) such a strong
>> feeling that Israel needs to be abolished, what sort of feelings will
>> the (say) 10000 deaths in the World Trade Center cause?
>>
>>
>> Brad DeLong
>
>So what should those of us in the rest of the world (the 'uncivilised' as
>American pundits increasingly call us) expect as result of your strong
>feelings? Are you trying to justify the next round of barbarism that will
>undoubtedly come soon or just explain it? If you're worried about it, what
>are you trying to do to prevent it or at least reduce its impact?

The line between explanation, understanding, justification, and excuse is always a fine one But anyone who wants to minimize the chances that the Gates of Hell are about to yawn open would be well-advised to talk less about how the WTC is "understandable given past misdeeds of the American government" and more about how massive civilian casualties--anywhere, anyhow, anytime--are unacceptable.

Brad DeLong



More information about the lbo-talk mailing list