Why do they hate us?

Seth Ackerman sia at nyc.rr.com
Thu Feb 28 16:48:54 PST 2002


Brad DeLong wrote:


> >I find it interesting at any rate that this question (Why do they
> >hate us?) is being raised in such a way as to make Americans
> >paranoid and to justify whatever measures the current regime wants
> >to take to curb civil liberties and repress any form of dissent.
> >Because the way they pursue this question, they are asserting 1)
> >that others hate us and 2) that others have no valid reason to feel
> >this way,
>
> Well, only 18% of the Gallup poll's Arab world sample believes that
> the World Trade Center atrocity was committed by Muslims from the
> Middle East, and that 60+% thinks it was committed by somebody
> else--which I think means "the Jews". This would seem to be evidence
> that some version of (1) and (2) may in fact be true...

Wait. The fact that people in Muslim countries doubt the Sept. 11 attacks were committed by Arabs is evidence that they hate "us" and have "no valid reason to feel this way"? Where's the logic here?

Seth



More information about the lbo-talk mailing list