An Invitation Ruffles Philosophical Feathers

Peter K. peterk at enteract.com
Sat Jun 29 10:05:07 PDT 2002



>>For his part, Mr. West seemed strangely unaffected by the
>>furor. Reached by telephone on Thursday, he said he had no
>>memory of being invited to the conference and learned of
>>the boycott only when a reporter contacted him last week.
>>Still, he said he was eager to attend. "I have learned much
>>from the art criticism of Kramer, the fine historiography
>>of Himmelfarb, the intellectual history of Diggins and some
>>of the essays of Kristol," he said serenely. "I just see
>>through their nonsense."

I thought West was being a wise-acre but apparently not.
>From Alterman's latest column:
http://www.thenation.com/doc.mhtml?i=20020715&s=alterman

"One wonders just what is so frightening. Perhaps it is a sense of being outgunned. I have seen West debate the elder Podhoretz at a conference sponsored by the Whitney Humanities Center at Yale, and the two proved so mismatched I left feeling a little sorry for Norman. Equally likely, however, is the fear that a leftist like West will remind audiences that their putative hero died a proud socialist. He may have been a fanatical anti-Communist, but his passions derived from an honest engagement in the life of the mind, something the neocons long ago forfeited in their love affair with power.

Ironically, West told Sam Tanenhaus that he didn't know he had been invited to the conference and was wholly unaware of having caused a conservative boycott. He explained, however, that he had been planning to go anyway--as a spectator. He saw a notice about it in The New York Review of Books and looked forward to catching up on the recent scholarship on Hook. West recalled that back in 1985 he had flown from California to Washington, DC, to be present for Hook's Jefferson Lecture and had the opportunity to tell the then-83-year-old philosopher how important his work had been to him. "



More information about the lbo-talk mailing list