Chomsky News Network

Micheal Ellis onyxmirr at earthlink.net
Thu May 30 12:31:30 PDT 2002



>At 02:18 PM 5/30/02 -0400, Chuck Munson wrote:
>
>>Kelley: You are out of touch with the mood of America.
>
>
>if you hadn't noticed, i wasn't giving you a synopsis of the mood of
>america! you have that pulpit, so bang away. i was pointing out how chomsky
>might have played to whatever was out there just a tad better than he did.

but "playing to the crowd" would be very un-chomsky like. infact that is prob his most admirable trait IMO


>i DID say that i think USers want to know the motivation for one's
>critique. If the critique is that there is utterly nothing good about the
>US, then the critics points won't get very far. who wants to hear about
>what shits they are. does that encourage you to listen to someone who's
>criticizing you and your behavior. or does it come off better if someone
>reminds you off your own ideals and expects you to live up to them?

i've never interpreted anything he said as being critical of the behavior of the american populace.....but quite the opposite and he shouldn't pander to any misrepresentation of his views. start doing that and one is on the road to internalizing say the "consensus" opinion which is most often manipulated for the services of power. if that is not a near universal truism then there aren't any.

~M.E.



More information about the lbo-talk mailing list