<HTML><FONT FACE=arial,helvetica><FONT SIZE=2>#8
<BR>MoscowTimes
<BR>October31, 2002
<BR>Editorial
<BR>DistinguishTerrorism From Separatism
<BR>
<BR>EditorialBy branding the Congress of the Chechen People a terrorist
<BR>gatheringand pushing for the arrest of Akhmed Zakayev, the Kremlin may
<BR>havefurther solidified domestic support for more resolute use of force in
<BR>dealingwith the Chechnya problem.
<BR>
<BR>But thereality is that not every Chechen separatist is a terrorist, even
<BR>thoughsome refugees have become so radicalized in the course of the brutal
<BR>Chechenwar that they openly supported the seizure of innocent civilians in
<BR>Moscowand wished they were part of the hostage-taking group.
<BR>
<BR>Russiashould stop trying to portray all Chechens who favor
<BR>self-determinationas ruthless butchers acting on the orders of
<BR>internationalterrorist networks that the international community should
<BR>joinforces against. The self-determination aspirations of a formidable
<BR>part ofthe Chechen people is Russia's domestic problem, which no
<BR>internationalanti-terrorist coalition would solve for the Kremlin.
<BR>
<BR>Russiashould try to distinguish between terrorism and separatism -- even
<BR>thoughthe division line between them can be blurred -- using adequate and
<BR>proportionateforce to cope with the former, but not the latter.
<BR>
<BR>It isclear that by failing to personally condemn the hostage-taking before
<BR>thestandoff was over, Aslan Maskhadov has discredited himself. But
<BR>civilizedproponents of self-determination of Chechnya, who oppose
<BR>terrorismas a means to achieve their goal, have not ceased to exist with
<BR>thediscrediting of Maskhadov, whose five-year term as president expired
<BR>earlythis year.
<BR>
<BR>Andmore bullets and bombs will not kill these aspirations of
<BR>self-determinationbut radicalize them, as was the case with Dzhokhar
<BR>Dudayevand Aslan Maskhadov.
<BR>
<BR>Thereshould be no doubt what this brutalized nation would opt for if given
<BR>the immediateopportunity to vote on self-determination -- and that would
<BR>be anunacceptable development for the Kremlin.
<BR>
<BR>But theKremlin can take one step without shedding control of the republic
<BR>andthat is holding elections for a Chechen parliament. This would give
<BR>proponentsof nonviolent self-determination legitimate representation and
<BR>stillallow for the establishment of a presidential republic.
<BR>
<BR>TheKremlin can also soften the grievances of the people by stopping the
<BR>indiscriminateuse of force and encouraging economic and social development
<BR>of thisravaged land.
<BR>
<BR>Ifsafety and decent living standards would not decrease the Chechen
<BR>people'sdesire to break away from Russia, then nothing will.
<BR>
<BR>But ifrepresentation in parliament and the reality of a safe and
<BR>relativelyprosperous Chechnya lead separatists to abandon the idea of
<BR>usingviolence to achieve their goals, then the Kremlin could hope that
<BR>theseproponents of self-determination could become what Gerry Adams and
<BR>SinnFein have become for Northern Ireland.
<BR>
<BR></FONT></HTML>