On Tue, 1 Apr 2003, Doug Henwood wrote:
> Miles Jackson wrote:
>
> >Catharsis is a fundamental concept for Freud. Release the
> >unconscious conflict indirectly (e.g., by watching violent
> >sports or Macbeth), and direct manifestations of aggression
> >should be reduced. That's psychoanalysis 101 as I
> >understand it!
>
> Rather an early one. It's a much more extended process than that (as
> any Woody Allen fan knows), involving lots of association, narrative,
> speculation, introspection, reliving, recalling.... There's hardly
> some magic cathartic moment. And there's also the transferrence, the
> mix of real and fantastic attachment to the shrink, which is quite
> mysterious and powerful.
>
> Doug
Okay, I see what you're getting at. I agree, the therapeutic practice of p-a is not just catharsis. All the other processes you mention are significant in p-a therapy too. I was thinking in terms of p-a as the source of testable scientific hypotheses about human behavior, not just p-a as a therapeutic tool.
Miles