Anti-war movement, Blair
JBrown72073 at cs.com
JBrown72073 at cs.com
Sun Feb 9 21:16:13 PST 2003
billbartlett writes:
>But Americans seem to be appalled by this kind of frankness. It isn't just
>about fawning to their leaders, it seems to be how they debate amongst
>themselves. Americans are just very sensitive types.
>
>Debating yanks on this list is like having a discussion with my aged spinster
>great aunt, a life-long member of the Salvation Army. I have to tread so
>carefully, not say anything that might upset their delicate sensitivities
>and when I slip up I get adult men stacking on a terrible turn and shrieking
>hysterically about how rude and uncouth I am. Yet from my point of view,
>I've been going easy on them.
There's a politics to that, of course. For example, it's one of the things
women aren't supposed to do, argue. Arguments among women, no matter how
contentful, are condemned as catfights because women are supposed to be
polite and nonthreatening (and not incidentally unable to get our shit
together by having real discussions.) I remember a couple of years ago
arguing with two women friends in an airport and a random guy walking the
other direction told us, "You're all wrong." He knew cause we were arguing,
see? And we hadn't even gotten warmed up! Professionals are stuffed in the
same box. New Yorkers are condemned for being argumentative, and working
class people (especially women) are 'too loud' all around. I say pour it on.
Jenny Brown
More information about the lbo-talk
mailing list