[lbo-talk] Democratic Communism

Michael Pugliese debsian at pacbell.net
Mon Nov 10 15:13:32 PST 2003


Replacing the army and the police with an armed
> citizenry would be on the road to a stateless society...

The USA has a heavily armed citizenry. Wouldn't be surprised to find this nation of 281 million+ has 560 million guns. Not that the police and all the other repressive apparati don't have tons more, but, we are not on the road to an anarchist stateless society, at least on the above signpost.

http://www.oup.com/us/catalog/general/subject/?view=usa&ci=0195137930 100 billion dollars. That is the annual cost of gun violence in America according to the authors of this landmark study, a book destined to change the way Americans view the problem of gun-related violence.

L Until now researchers have assessed the burden imposed by gunshot injuries and deaths in terms of medical costs and lost productivity. Here, economists Philip Cook and Jens Ludwig widen the lens, developing a framework to calculate the full costs borne by Americans in a society where both gun violence and its ever-present threat mandate responses that touch every aspect of our lives.

L All of us, no matter where we reside or how we live, share the costs of gun violence. Whether waiting in line to pass through airport security or paying taxes for the protection of public officials; whether buying a transparent book bag for our children to meet their school's post-Columbine regulations or subsidizing an urban trauma center, the steps we take are many and the expenditures enormous. L Cook and Ludwig reveal that investments in prevention, avoidance, and harm reduction, both public and private, constitute a far greater share of the gun-violence burden than previously recognized. They also employ extensive survey data to measure the subjective costs of living in a society where there is risk of being shot or losing a loved one or neighbor to gunfire.

L At the same time, they demonstrate that the problem of gun violence is not intractable. Their review of the available evidence suggests that there are both additional gun regulations and targeted law enforcement measures that will help.

L This urgently needed book documents for the first time how gun violence diminishes the quality of life for everyone in America. In doing so, it will move the debate over gun violence past symbolic politics to a direct engagement with the costs and benefits of policies that hold promise for reducing gun violence and may even pay for themselves. Features Shows huge disparities among demographic groups in the risk of homicide and injury, but far more evenly distributed costs of gun violence Is the first book to apply contingent valuation techniques to firearms injury Outlines an agenda for reducing gun violence, and attempts to compare the costs with the benefits of such efforts Reviews

"The first effort to make a comprehensive estimate of the price the nation pays for criminal shootings, gun accidents, and suicides committed with guns."--The New York Times

"Marshalls new information and research to present a compelling picture of the true dimensions and extraordinary costs of gun violence in the United States. The book also debunks some of the key arguments of the NRA and its academic defenders....What makes Cook and Ludwig's book novel is their careful effort to calculate the total costs of gun violence."--The American Prospect

-- Michael Pugliese



More information about the lbo-talk mailing list