[lbo-talk] [Fwd: Re: Ralph Nader, Unsafe at any Speed-not in my name]

Carrol Cox cbcox at ilstu.edu
Sun Feb 22 12:44:54 PST 2004


The position condemned in the following fwd from psn has been defended by some on this list; it has even more often been ascribed as the generic position of "marxist revolutionaries," usually without even an example of it being given. I think Alan's position has been the basic position of nearly all marxists of all times and places. Alan's position is mine. If anyone ever ascribe's a position similar to Nate's (quoted below) to me, I wish in advance to brand that person a liar. I have never in my 39 years of political activity (I was 35 when I became active) advocated such an absurd position as "the worse the better." I don't know any serious marxist who has..

Years ago a friend in the Spanish department at ISU use to stop by my office to argue politics. We would get along fine until he would tell me that as a marxist I had to believe "the worse the better." At which time I would always say, "Get the fuck out of my office, Gordon." This identical conversation was repeated a number of times. :-)

Carrol

-------- Original Message -------- Subject: Re: Ralph Nader, Unsafe at any Speed-not in my name

Date: Sun, 22 Feb 2004 08:07:04 -0800 (PST)

From: Alan Spector <a_spector at sbcglobal.net>

To: psn at csf.colorado.edu

While I respect Nate's genuine sincerity and I share in his frustration at the slowness of social change, and I share some of his skepticism about the Democrats, I really have to completely separate myself from this comment (excerpted below) of his:

Nate Breznau <nbreznau2112 at hotmail.com> wrote: So I submit that there is a good chance that I will vote 3rd party. If Bush gets elected it might actually be SO bad that it creates some more serious social movements in our apathetic country. -Nate

As I've written before, I know very few on the left who take the discredited position of "the worse it gets for people, the more they will rebel, and then good change will come about." I guess there are a few, after all.

But do not characterize the entire "more militant" left was having that position. Many of them/us work very hard, day in and day out, with grassroots people, to try to ameliorate the misery of capitalism as we build a movement against it. Harder, perhaps, than many (I didn't say "all") of the Democratic Party supporters whose only contribution is to vote.

Our criticisms of "moderates" is not that we reject a practical, partial gain for others because we want to hold to our own pure philosophies. Our criticisms come from a practical concern that the "moderate capitalists" will continue to oppress hundreds of millions (not a small number) and furthermore, that the grassroots movement to ameliorate and eventually fundamentally change the racist, abusive capitalist system will be weakened, even controlled and essentially destroyed if it is led by the capitalists.

But our criticisms are not based on the foolish idea that if the working class can be damaged even more, then they will fight back. If you purposefully work to damage the lives of the working class, they will correctly blame YOU as part of the problem. Alan Spector



More information about the lbo-talk mailing list