And would a different kind of war in Afghanistan have been so bad? The Taliban were one of the most thuggish regimes on earth and a war meant to restore basic human rights and clean out Al Qaeda would hardly have been a bad thing. That's not the war that was fought and I never thought it would be, which is why I opposed Bush's war, but yes, there are "kinder, gentler wars" that are more admirable and acceptable than the straight-up conquering and looting operations that the Bush folks seem dedicated to.
And someone like Chomsky, who concentrates on foreign policy where the differences in the parties are least signficant, knows well the difference between the parties on domestic policy. From civil rights to labor rights, the differences are massive.
Nathan Newman