[lbo-talk] I am a committed Leninist

Michael Pugliese michael098762001 at earthlink.net
Sat May 29 08:29:21 PDT 2004


"Ask Dr. Science!" was a long running funny public radio skit by Ian Scholes. http://www.ducksbreath.com/

I'd rather ask Dr. Gouldner or Lichtheim, thank you, Dr. Brown. http://www2.pfeiffer.edu/~lridener/DSS/Marx/2marxtoc.htm http://www2.pfeiffer.edu/~lridener/DSS/Marx/ch2.htm MARXISM AS SCIENCE AND CRITIQUE

Charles is giving y'all the old stale orthodoxies (that Maurice Cornforth, one of his sources, repudiated in his last book, "Communism and Philosophy, " Lawrence & Wishart, circa '80) that the Frankfurt School and other , "critical marxists, " opposed to the, pseudo- scientific marxism ala Engels. Scientism really. David McLellan, marxologist in his, "Marxism After Marx: An Introduction, " cites these studies, to which I'd add these two, the 1st volume of Leszek Kolakowski's, "Msain Currents of Marxism, " and A. Walicki, "Marxism and the Leap to the Kingdom of Freedom." http://etext.lib.virginia.edu/cgi-local/DHI/dhi.cgi?id=dv2-51
> ...Z. A. Jordan, The Evolution of Dialectical Materialism:
A Philosophical and Sociological Analysis (London, 1967) is the best introduction to this subject. Starting from the now generally accepted distinction between the original approach of Engels and that of Marx, the author traces in considerable detail the exfoliation of Engels' unsystematic essays into the fully developed system of dialectical mate- rialism first outlined by G. V. Plekhanov and subsequently codified by Lenin and his successors, down to and including Stalin. Gustav A. Wetter, Dialectical Materialism: A Histori- cal And Systematic Survey of Philosophy in the Soviet Union (London, 1958), offers an equally learned, but differently organized, account of the topic, the author giving little space to Marx and Engels, while centering attention upon the evolution of Soviet philosophy since 1917. Unlike Jordan, he deals at some length with Bukharin, Deborin, and some lesser figures. For a critique of Engels' philo sophical writings see Sidney Hook, “Dialectic and Nature,� in his Reason, Social Myths and Democracy (New York, 1950), pp. 183ff. For the impact of Leninism on the philo- sophical and scientific discussions in the USSR before the full rigor mortis of Stalinism set in, see David Joravsky, Soviet Marxism and Natural Science 1917-32 (London, 1961). For a more recent and less technical discussion of Marxism- Leninism as a pseudo-ontological system of speculation about nature and history see A. James Gregor, A Survey of Marxism (New York, 1965). The brief reading list ap- pended to this work provides a guide to official Soviet literature on the subject, as well as to works by Western authors and a few “revisionist� critics of Leninism who have retained the Hegelian-Marxist approach antedating the formulation of Soviet orthodoxy in the 1930's. For a brief but pregnant discussion of this latter theme, see Eugene Kamenka, Philosophy in the Soviet Union, Philosophy (Journal of the Royal Institute of Philosophy), 38, No. 143 (Jan., 1963). GEORGE LICHTHEIM <SNIP> ...



More information about the lbo-talk mailing list