[lbo-talk] Al From Beats Tambourine

Carl Remick carlremick at hotmail.com
Wed Nov 17 08:22:44 PST 2004



>From: "Nathan Newman" <nathanne at nathannewman.org>
>
>>From: "Carl Remick" <carlremick at hotmail.com
>>
>>[This is the best advice anyone has offered since the Rev. Jim Jones
>>suggested sampling the grape-flavored Kool-Aid.]
>
>Why is this bad advice? Large majorities of the population are religious
>in this country. Figuring out how to appeal to those groups based on
>religious appeals by progressive religious activists seems like a
>no-brainer. That doens't even require changing any substantive views, even
>on social issues; it just requires messengers and active organizing among
>religious voters by progressive religious organizers. This is already done
>regularly in black churches. Expanding that effort more systematically to
>white and latino churches hardly seems like "kool-aid drinking" advice.

[Screw the religious, and I say that with deep sincerity. What a vile, pestilential influence these otherworldly psychotics are. Nicholas von Hoffman has a good piece in the current NY Observer that discusses how poisonous holiness is to US politics:]

Now Is Not the Time For National Unity!

By Nicholas von Hoffman

A little disunity, please. Let’s get divisive, gang. No national healing—raw wounds, anger and resentment. This is the moment for accusations and recriminations.

As per the routine used by countless other defeated politicians, John Kerry wrapped up a quavering call for unity and oneness inside his tardy concession speech. "In the days ahead, we must find common cause. We must join in common effort," quoth the fallen leader of the failed effort. Yeah, yeah, yeah, link arms with George W. Bush and … and what? Mr. Kerry’s answer was forget politics and take it up with the local divinity.

"I leave this campaign with a prayer that has even greater meaning to me now that I’ve come to know our vast country so much better thanks to all of you, and what a privilege it has been to do so," he said. "And that prayer is very simple: God bless America."

Unity and prayer. I cannot think of a less helpful farewell sentiment....

Unity in our situation means endorsing aggression, invasion, torture and assassination. It means indifference to the working poor, the fastest-growing major segment in our population. Small wonder that calls for unity and backing George Bush are coupled with the imperative to pray—but, fellow liberals and lefties, God doesn’t answer Democratic prayers. God is a Republican.

The Christian clergy of the United States was either pro-Bush or silent. When Mr. Kerry was condemned by a group of bishops in his own church, there was no countervailing group of bishops stepping forward to defend him. Organized Christian religion is either controlled by the other side or indifferent, or too weak and spineless to defy Republican godliness. Mr. Kerry, having to deal with the hostility of organized religion, chose to play the other side’s game. You cannot blame him for going publicly pious in self-defense: No significant Democratic voice took on religion. The major figures, as much intimidated as Mr. Kerry, shut up and played pious, too. Mr. Kerry was reduced to telling the world that when he was fighting in Vietnam he carried a rosary in his pocket. How undignified is that? But given how he was left out to dry, he cannot be fairly criticized.

Taking on religion, and the superstition and obscurantism which characterize it, is not the job of somebody running for public office in America. Somebody else had better start fighting back, however, before a new species of the Dark Ages is upon us, and faith-based mobs begin breaking into scientific laboratories and smashing the test tubes. If the Republicans want to talk values, then let us talk values, because some of their values are pretty damn ugly.

Let us talk about religion and reaction in America, now and then. The alliance between the Republicans and the churches is no new thing: The Christian clergy has a long history of siding with the big money and the powerful. Be meek and get your butt kicked. The job of taking on organized religion should not be left to well-meaning but ineffectual groups working on keeping church and state separated. This is much bigger, more insidious and more dangerous than dragging a stone with the Ten Commandments on it in front of the courthouse.


>From defeat, if we can take nothing else, take disunity, division and a
refusal to shut down the liberal spirit. And one more thing: The next time you hear a politician call for prayer or give a "God bless," boo!

<http://www.observer.com/pages/observer.asp>

Carl



More information about the lbo-talk mailing list