[lbo-talk] When to Talk About Socialism

Carrol Cox cbcox at ilstu.edu
Mon Nov 22 09:05:31 PST 2004


Over the last 37 years I have talked to various people at various times about socialism, past, present, future. What _all_ those occasions had in common was that the person I was talking to was already engaged in various kinds of social/political struggle, and _on his/her own_ had reached the point where he/she consciously needed to know more about the enemy. That involved necessarily looking at the present as history -- i.e. looking _back on_ the present from a perspective in the future -- looking at capitalism from the perspective of a socialist society. And that, of course, involved talking in general terms about socialism. But I have _never_ talked about socialism for the purposes of persuading someone to be a socialist. One does not "convert" people to socialism. It is not a religion of which one can say "Whosoever believeth in me shall not perish" (or something like that). There is no moral or metaphysical merit in believing in socialism -- it gets you no brownie points with the god who doesn't exist. People become socialists when and only when they find that it is the only way to make sense of the world they are living in _now_.

That is why I never have and never will discuss socialism on this list.

Carrol

"The anatomy of man is a key to the anatomy of the ape." (MECW 28:42) Nowhere does Marx suggest that the anatomy of the ape is of much help in understanding the anatomy of h.sapiens.



More information about the lbo-talk mailing list