[lbo-talk] Derrida dead

Ted Winslow egwinslow at rogers.com
Mon Oct 11 07:56:01 PDT 2004


A Guardian editorialist wrote:


> He should be remembered as a profound thinker who
> made a lasting contribution to intellectual discourse.
>
> Deconstruction, in terms of literary theory, springs from a simple idea
> that originated with Friedrich Nietzsche: that any text is open to an
> infinite number of interpretations. That makes it possible to ignore
> the
> author's intentions, stated or otherwise, and examine a text for
> meanings
> that would otherwise be uncomfortable or hidden. This thought is little
> different to some of Ludwig Wittgenstein's ideas, but by concentrating
> on
> epistemology he avoided the obloquy heaped on Derrida.

That idea that my experience is completely constructed by me has as its logical implication "solipsism of the present moment." When applied to language it implies that communication is impossible because the meaning of language to me is my subjective construction; it has nothing to do with any meaning outside of me. In the above, this is ignored and claims are made about the meaning of Derrida and Wittgenstein, Derrida's meaning being that it's impossible to know what Derrida or anyone else means.

Radical skepticism is absurd; it's explainable as the product of the same structure of self I mentioned earlier, namely, a extremely weak unintegrated ego whose experience has significant delusional aspects. These prevent it from being experience of anything real. One of these aspects is the product of the sadistic attack on linking. It's this that makes language meaningless by fragmenting it into meaningless bits. The "meaning" this is hidden in this way is "the overwhelming" constructed through projective identification, a meaning only accessible through "mysticism" (assuming your able to see that that you can't self-consistently claim to be able to access it through "science"). So you get to it via a mistaken, i.e. a "mystical," "reading" of Antigone.

Ted



More information about the lbo-talk mailing list