[lbo-talk] Virtually all Dems support Card Check Bill

Doug Henwood dhenwood at panix.com
Mon Oct 25 10:03:33 PDT 2004


Nathan Newman wrote:


>----- Original Message -----
>From: "Doug Henwood" <dhenwood at panix.com>
>
>
>Nathan Newman wrote:
>>Or do you really think big rallies in Washington, D.C. are intimidating to
>>GOP Senators from Red states?
>
>-They might be, if there were actually big rallies (plural).
>
>I don't buy it. A small delegation from THEIR OWN STATE is far more
>powerful, or better yet, a large vote on election day that scares the shit
>out of them. Look at Arlen Specter, who is facing life-and-death in
>Pennsylvania with Dem mobilization and has signed up as the only GOP
>Senator in support of the EFCA.
>
>A rally that doesn't translate into votes or the threat of a votes at
>reelection has no effect. The left loves rallies but they are way
>overrated for political effect. The ones that have an effect are those
>that are unexpected in some way, but the reality is that any large
>constituency can turn out some number of folks at a rally, so it's usually
>a waste of effort to prove something that everyone in Washington already
>knows you can do.

It's not necessarily the rallies themselves - it's what they'd signify about the level of mobilization and consciousness. Of course rallies alone wouldn't affect all that much, but a real MWM would show that the status quo was under challenge. You probably wouldn't get the kind of votes you're talking about without that level of mobilization either.

Doug



More information about the lbo-talk mailing list