[lbo-talk] Re: genocide, and" ordinary" murder

frank scott frank at marin.cc.ca.us
Tue Apr 5 11:27:48 PDT 2005



>
>
>"...I doubt that the legend of the
>motto "the only good Indian is a dead Indian" reflects no reality of the
>time. That general anti-Indian ideology is conveyed to us through many
>sources. That general pattern is _some_ evidence of the states of mind, the
>mens rea ,of the specific soldiers in the area of the Mandan. It gives rise
>to a presumption of genocidal intent ..."
>

quite apart form any scholarship or lack of it on churchill's part, that spirit of hateful reduction of the enemy is part and parcel of the warrior mindset, in any conflict...the opposition is monstrous, evil, and unfit to live...and it is not a legend at all, since i remember it clearly from my childhood during the second world war, when i heard, and saw the words, "the only good jap is a dead jap" and feel certain the same was said about germans... though i have no distinct memory of that, but recall a quote from the older churchill, the murderous winston, that they (germans) should all be wiped from the face of the earth ( only a slight paraphrase, and only one of many bloody hateful utterances from that western hero about the german "race")

that kind of verbal murder is regular speech, engaged in, but learned, by not only the warriors but the population most brain bludgeoned by propaganda about the enemy...if that is evidence of genocide, that overused word has become even more useless...

we might as well say schiavo was a victim of genocide, which is probably what many believe...

fs



More information about the lbo-talk mailing list