[lbo-talk] Ward Churchill

Luke Weiger lweiger at umich.edu
Fri Feb 4 15:44:32 PST 2005


Correct me if I misrepresent his argument. It seems to go someting like this:

Premise: The US is just as bad as Nazi Germany (doesn't pass the laugh test, but I'll grant it anyway) Premise: Resistance is the proper response to a state as bad as Nazi Germany (right, but as should be clear in a moment, much depends on the form and purpose of the resistance) Conclusion: Bombing the towers was a laudable act

Big problem: only a political and moral idiot would've supported terrorizing German civialians prior to WWII



More information about the lbo-talk mailing list