[lbo-talk] O'Reilly vs Churchill: treason? sedition?

Doug Henwood dhenwood at panix.com
Wed Feb 9 20:20:22 PST 2005


Just saw O'Reilly interviewing a former JAG, Somebody Noone. O'Reilly was grilling him on whether it was possible to get Churchill for treason or sedition. The JAG said no, but O'R clearly wanted to hear a yes.

Chuck Grimes asked me offlist why I didn't want any discussion of Churchill's footnoting practices. It's a good question, and here's what I said:


>I'm afraid it'd be a lot of people talking about what they don't
>know much about. Also, I gotta say, it makes me nervous that pissing
>on Churchill's scholarship will contribute something to minimizing
>the horror of Indian genocide. So what if he got some details wrong,
>white people did kill 90% of them and still treat them like shit.

Doug



More information about the lbo-talk mailing list