[lbo-talk] Stalin worship, kulaks, Shanin's analysis

martin mschiller at pobox.com
Wed Jan 12 12:20:53 PST 2005


On Jan 12, 2005, at 10:15 AM, andie nachgeborenen wrote:


> I
> say that it is essential to a proper appraisal of the
> Stalinist system, which is no longer really an object
> to be defended, but merely assessed. I don't dismiss
> the positive aspects of the Soviet experience. But
> apart from insisting on the negative lessons of total
> planning, I see no point in apologizing for the
> intentional evils and cruelty of the Stalinist
> dictatorship. Note that I reject the high body counts
> of the likes of Conquest and Solzhentisn -- I go with
> Getty's and Davies' much lower figures. But the lowest
> of those figures give us 8 million dead in the planned
> famine in the Ukraine.
>

It seems that what you describe as kulaks might be anti-communist, being ambitious and focused on self. Then they died because state power decided that communism's survival was threatened.

What assessment do you draw from that observation?

Martin



More information about the lbo-talk mailing list