[lbo-talk] Appeal to Ignorance

Luke Weiger lweiger at umich.edu
Mon Jun 13 13:24:53 PDT 2005


Kelley wrote:


> uh. no. that's not quite it. which is to say, plenty of marxist-feminists
> and socialist-feminists can talk about women's oppression _and_ class
> analysis. They just don't reduce class analysis to one historical era.
They
> talk about class society. Whether you buy their arguments or not --
'nother
> story. Same thing with Miles.

Well, try cashing out the notion of "all religious history is the history of class struggle" in an interesting (i.e. non-trivial) and plausible fashion. I don't think it's possible.


> also, i'm not sure what spiritual yearning has to do with anything. what
does it mean, anyway?

Many people desperately yearn to believe that they'll continue to exist even after their bodies expire. They also yearn for the sort of ultimate explanations of the origins and order of the universe that science can't provide. Hence many people are all too credulous of the balderdash we call "religion."

-- Luke



More information about the lbo-talk mailing list