[lbo-talk] Re: film crit

[frank scott]

"... you left the realm of film criticism when you imposed a reading on
the film that has no material basis in
the mise en scene you experienced.  ... to have some validity should
criticism not have some
relation to the object being critiqued?"

not in the "missing scene" school of criticism, in which the viewer
supplies that scene, which was left out by the director...

fs