[lbo-talk] Commissar Proyect Denouncement:

Doug Henwood dhenwood at panix.com
Tue May 10 09:32:41 PDT 2005


Michael Dawson wrote:


> > He presented an argument, and a fairly well-reasoned one. Since
>> when does arguing a position vigorously make one a Commissar?
>>
>> Carrol
>
>P.S. Speaking of inability to read, what is LP's argument, Cadet? It's
>that Jared Diamond is a greenwasher because 10 pages in his 600 page book
>place excessive trust in a corporation. No mention in LP's review of any
>redeeming quality in the reviewed work. Upshot? Don't read it; it's trash.
>
>Golly, that doesn't sound like a Commissar at all, does it?
>
>You might have something thoughtful, rather than simply tribal, on this
>issue, if you hadn't stopped reading books in 1963.

This is completely unnecessary. Proyect doesn't deserve all the attention.

Doug



More information about the lbo-talk mailing list